Since 1923 • For a greater Loyola

The Maroon

Since 1923 • For a greater Loyola

The Maroon

Since 1923 • For a greater Loyola

The Maroon

Students embrace different brands of ice cream in the Orleans Room

Christian+Williams%2C+biochemistry+freshman%2C+scoops+ice+cream+in+the+Orleans+Room.+Blue+Bell+ice+cream+used+to+be+served+at+Loyola%2C+until+it+was+recalled+last+year.+Photo+credit%3A+Molly+Olwig
Christian Williams, biochemistry freshman, scoops ice cream in the Orleans Room. Blue Bell ice cream used to be served at Loyola, until it was recalled last year. Photo credit: Molly Olwig

Returning from winter break, Loyola students were surprised to see that Blue Bunny and Edie’s Ice Cream has permanently replaced Blue Bell ice creams in the Orleans Room, despite the ice cream being back on shelves in stores.

The change occurred after Blue Bell Creameries stunned ice cream lovers across the map with a series of recalls after listeria was discovered in some of the products during testing in 2015.

With students curious to know if Blue Bell will return to the Orleans Room, Phoebe Carriere-Cook, Sodexo general manager, said that currently, Blue Bell is only producing the retail version of their ice cream found in local grocery store chains and no longer producing the three-pound versions that were previously purchased for the OR.

“There has been no decision made to bring Blue Bell back even if it was available. Sodexo has strict guidelines in regards to purchasing and food safety compliance audits,” Carriere-Cook said.

After Blue Bell redeemed themselves with shelving ice cream earlier this year that was supposedly free of bacteria, signs of listeria were found yet again at a Brenham, Texas plant.

While it was reported that listeria was not found in the area of the factory that produces the ice cream, many customers are still skeptical to purchase.

Julie Gauthier, visiting assistant professor of biological sciences, said that she would advise ice cream eaters to simply not purchase or consume Blue Bell to avoid getting sick.

“If the benefits outweigh the risks, then it would be okay to purchase, but this is not the case with Blue Bell,” Gauthier said.

Gauthier said that consuming ice cream that may contain listeria could cause flu-like symptoms such as nausea and stomachache, and could cause very serious infection and even brain damage, especially in expecting mothers. Elderly and those with HIV could also suffer from it severely.

“Washing the ice cream won’t kill it and keeping it for longer in the freezer definitely gives you a higher dose of the bacteria. That’s why they tell you not to keep things such as unpasteurized foods in the fridge and freezer longer,” Gauthier said.

While many students trust Blue Bell to take more precautions in the future, others disagree and don’t plan to go back.

Stephanie Magid, psychology senior, said she won’t be buying the ice cream for a while because she doesn’t like the risks and accidents that could occur from eating the ice cream.

“I don’t think I trust Blue Bell as a company. But I have faith in the Food and Drug Administration and other agencies that enforce health standards. If they say it’s safe to be on the market, then sure, I’ll assume it is,” Magid said.

For now, everyone awaits to see if Blue Bell Creameries will clean up their act for good.

“The fact that they let it happen again makes me feel dreary about it returning. I think for now, just let things calm down, and if there are no more incidents for another year, then maybe bring it back,” Gauthier said.

View Comments (1)
More to Discover
About the Contributor
Chasity Pugh, Social Media Producer for Facebook and Instagram
Chasity is a mass communication major with a concentration in journalism and minor in African American studies. Prior to serving as Social Media Producer for Facebook and Instagram for The Maroon, she served as a staff writer and Religion Editor. In her free time Chasity enjoys visiting art museums and serving her community, as well as a look or two. Contact: [email protected] or @chasitypugh_

Comments (1)

All The Maroon Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • J

    jeftuxedoFeb 2, 2016 at 10:00 am

    This article is stilted and inaccurate. There was no mention at all of the fact that now every batch of ice cream that is produced at Blue Bell is tested before it is released for public consumption. IF it tests positive for Listera M.-none of it has since Blue Bell resumed sales in August- it must be reported to the Texas, Oklahoma and Alabama regulatory agencies. Your shoddy “reporting” forgot to point those important facts out in your article. You also neglected to mention that Blue Bell has totally revamped their manufacturing procedures and cleaned and rebuilt their manufacturing plants to address these problems.

    Ms. Gauthier, you should be reprimanded (or better yet, sued) for your ignorant and slanderous remarks:

    “Julie Gauthier, visiting assistant professor of biological sciences, said that she would advise ice cream eaters to simply not purchase or consume Blue Bell to avoid getting sick.
    “If the benefits outweigh the risks, then it would be okay to purchase, but this is not the case with Blue Bell,” Gauthier said.

    What proof do you have that any consumer has gotten sick from eating Blue Bell Ice Cream now? You don’t have any; there haven’t been any new documented cases since the original findings of the CDC last May. Then you advise consumers to not buy it. Based on what evidence? Based on your own prejudices, I think.

    And you teach at a university? I pity the poor students that kind of education.

    Reply